In 1996, the quiet community of Riverhead, New York, was shaken to its core when Curtisha Morning’s lifeless body was discovered five weeks after her mysterious disappearance. The homecoming queen, stabbed a chilling 96 times, left the town in fear, suspecting the presence of a sexual killer among them.

The Shocking Arrest of Kalila Taylor

The arrest of Kalila Taylor for Curtisha’s murder added another layer of disbelief to the community. Prosecutors argued that Taylor’s motives were fueled by jealousy and love, asserting that she was enraged over Carl Brown, the father of Taylor’s child, redirecting his affections toward Curtisha.

Following two trials, Kalila Taylor found herself sentenced to 25 years to life for second-degree murder, leaving the community with mixed emotions.

A Silent Sentencing in 2012

In August 2012, a New York court handed down a minimum sentence of 25 years to Kalila Taylor. Interestingly, during the sentencing, Taylor chose to remain silent, offering no insights into her perspective. Her sister, Katisha, maintained Taylor’s innocence, expressing hope for a potential appeal.

Taylor’s attorney, John Loturco, committed to appealing the conviction without specifying the grounds, emphasizing Taylor’s consistent proclamation of innocence despite substantial evidence to the contrary.

The Enigma of Taylor’s Prison Life

Currently incarcerated at Albion Correctional Facility, Taylor has been eligible for parole since May 31, 2022. However, the question lingers—has she petitioned for release? Taylor’s life behind bars remains shrouded in mystery.

Parole Eligibility and Violent Predispositions

Parole eligibility hinges on good behavior, a factor Taylor struggled with before her arrest. Instances of violence peppered her past, including assaults in 1992, 1994, and a stabbing incident a month before Curtisha’s disappearance. Her tumultuous history, marked by a bar brawl and firing a gun near a crowd, paints a picture of an unpredictable and aggressive individual.

Suffolk County DA, Christopher Powers, once described Taylor as “an extremely violent and out-of-control young lady,” a sentiment echoed by Taylor’s involvement in multiple violent incidents.

The Shadow of Past Mistakes

Despite Taylor’s psychiatric care and completion of a medication and therapy regimen before her second trial, questions arise about her current mental state. If her penchant for violence persists, the likelihood of parole diminishes.

Legal Twists: Overturned Conviction

In a surprising turn, Taylor’s first conviction in 1997 was overturned due to a crucial mistake by the trial judge. District Attorney James M. Catterson acknowledged the lack of eyewitness testimony but emphasized the compelling scientific evidence.

The New York Appellate Division overturned the conviction, citing improper instructions to the jury. Judge Arthur Pitts’ error in categorizing DNA evidence as direct rather than circumstantial led to a retrial.

Rejecting Plea Deals and Family Support

Taylor’s resolve was evident in her rejection of two plea deals that could have reduced her minimum sentence. Curtisha’s family, now residing in North Carolina, flew back to Riverhead for Taylor’s second trial, seeking justice for their lost loved one.

Suffolk County District Attorney Janet Albertson expressed relief for the Morning family, acknowledging the quick and confident verdict delivered by the jury.

In the tangled web of the Kalila Taylor case, the search for truth continues. As the possibility of parole looms, the community and Curtisha’s family await answers, hoping for justice to prevail.

2 thought on “Kalila Taylor Case: A Tale of Murder, Jealousy, and Legal Twists”
  1. Pretty! This has been a really wonderful post. Many thanks for providing these details.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *